plasma-workspace-x11 was removed from F44 and F45 which is unacceptable in stable branch updates #3707

Closed
opened 2026-11-02 13:01:45 +00:00 by sergiomb · 9 comments

we don't have any request for remove x11 neither for update kde to 6.8 , I still use X11 in my setup and wayland i not an option

https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2026-2d6f409e34

I ask Fesco to revert these updates on F44 and F45 , as it was planned without kde 6.8

we don't have any request for remove x11 neither for update kde to 6.8 , I still use X11 in my setup and wayland i not an option https://bodhi.fedoraproject.org/updates/FEDORA-2026-2d6f409e34 I ask Fesco to revert these updates on F44 and F45 , as it was planned without kde 6.8
Member

Linking here a related agreement from F40 discussion: #3165 (comment)

At today's FESCo meeting, we agreed on the following proposal:

  • AGREED: KDE packages which reintroduce support for X11 are
    allowed in the main Fedora repositories, however they may not be
    included by default on any release-blocking deliverable (ISO, image,
    etc.). The KDE SIG should provide a notice before major changes, but
    is not responsible for ensuring that these packages adapt. Upgrades
    from F38 and F39 will be automatically migrated to Wayland. (+5, 0,
    -1)

For additional clarification: this means that all users performing upgrades MUST be migrated to the Wayland session. They then MAY opt-in to the X11 session by installing a package for that purpose. We are explicitly not providing detailed technical implementation requirements here, but we expect all parties to follow the spirit of this decision when making technical decisions.

The KDE SIG has an update exception to keep the KDE stack up to date in Fedora: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Updates_Policy/#_exceptions / https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/SIGs/KDE/Update_policy

Keeping Fedora 44 on Plasma 6.7 is not realistic. Fedora 44 EOL is Wed 2027-06-02 and the last KDE Plasma 6.7.7 point release is planned for Tue 2027-01-19. Not updating Fedora 45 is not even an option.

Moreover, users expect the KDE stack to be up to date with upstream releases in Fedora. It's part of what makes Fedora KDE a compelling offering.

The KDE SIG has deprecated X11 support in Fedora 40 (https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/KDE_Plasma_6) thus removal could happen at any time and it happened as upstream deprecated support.

If you want to keep X11 support in Fedora, you should take over maintenance of the components dropped by upstream in the Plasma 6.8 release. The other option is to keep building the KDE Plasma 6.7 packages in a COPR.

Linking here a related agreement from F40 discussion: https://forge.fedoraproject.org/fesco/tickets/issues/3165#issuecomment-832626 > At today's FESCo meeting, we agreed on the following proposal: > > * AGREED: KDE packages which reintroduce support for X11 are > allowed in the main Fedora repositories, however they may not be > included by default on any release-blocking deliverable (ISO, image, > etc.). The KDE SIG should provide a notice before major changes, but > is not responsible for ensuring that these packages adapt. Upgrades > from F38 and F39 will be automatically migrated to Wayland. (+5, 0, > -1) > > For additional clarification: this means that all users performing upgrades MUST be migrated to the Wayland session. They then MAY opt-in to the X11 session by installing a package for that purpose. We are explicitly not providing detailed technical implementation requirements here, but we expect all parties to follow the spirit of this decision when making technical decisions. The KDE SIG has an update exception to keep the KDE stack up to date in Fedora: https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Updates_Policy/#_exceptions / https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/SIGs/KDE/Update_policy Keeping Fedora 44 on Plasma 6.7 is not realistic. [Fedora 44 EOL is Wed 2027-06-02](https://fedorapeople.org/groups/schedule/f-44/f-44-key-tasks.html) and the last KDE Plasma 6.7.7 point release [is planned for Tue 2027-01-19](https://community.kde.org/Schedules/Plasma_6). Not updating Fedora 45 is not even an option. Moreover, users expect the KDE stack to be up to date with upstream releases in Fedora. It's part of what makes Fedora KDE a compelling offering. The KDE SIG has deprecated X11 support in Fedora 40 (https://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Changes/KDE_Plasma_6) thus removal could happen at any time and it happened as upstream deprecated support. If you want to keep X11 support in Fedora, you should take over maintenance of the components dropped by upstream in the Plasma 6.8 release. The other option is to keep building the KDE Plasma 6.7 packages in a COPR.
Member

If it was not clear from my message above, I'm -1

If it was not clear from my message above, I'm -1
Member

For the same reason, I'm -1 as well.

For the same reason, I'm -1 as well.
Member

-1

-1
zbyszek changed title from plasma-workspace-x11 was remove from F44 and F45 which is unacceptable in stable branch updates. to plasma-workspace-x11 was remove from F44 and F45 which is unacceptable in stable branch updates 2026-11-03 12:18:26 +00:00
zbyszek changed title from plasma-workspace-x11 was remove from F44 and F45 which is unacceptable in stable branch updates to plasma-workspace-x11 was removed from F44 and F45 which is unacceptable in stable branch updates 2026-11-03 17:14:28 +00:00
Member

This will be discussed during the meeting today (the meeting starts in three quarters of an hour, but this topic is third on the agenda).

This will be discussed during the meeting today (the meeting starts in three quarters of an hour, but this topic is third on the agenda).
Member

This was discussed during the meeting today. We want to collect a list of tools that depend on the components being removed. Please list those here or in the releng ticket. wrong ticket

~~This was discussed during the meeting today. We want to collect a list of tools that depend on the components being removed. Please list those here or in the releng ticket.~~ wrong ticket
Member

This was discussed during the meeting today:
AGREED: (Rejected (-8, ∓1, +0)

This was discussed during the meeting today: AGREED: (Rejected (-8, ∓1, +0)
Author

https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Updates_Policy/#philosophy

Updates should aim to fix bugs, and not introduce features, particularly when those features would materially affect the user or developer experience.

https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/fesco/Updates_Policy/#philosophy Updates should aim to fix bugs, and not introduce features, particularly when those features would materially affect the user or developer experience.
Owner

Yes, thats correct, but here we have a number of competing things:

  • The older version is going out of support by upstream and downstream cannot commit to maintaining it for the rest of the fedora release cycle on their own.
  • The upstream release cycle is faster than the fedora release cycle, so we need to upgrade more quickly than fedora releases allow (this is why kde has a updates exception).

It's unfortunate, but the support was going to go away sooner or later, just having to update to keep things supported means it's perhaps faster than folks thought it would be.

Yes, thats correct, but here we have a number of competing things: * The older version is going out of support by upstream and downstream cannot commit to maintaining it for the rest of the fedora release cycle on their own. * The upstream release cycle is faster than the fedora release cycle, so we need to upgrade more quickly than fedora releases allow (this is why kde has a updates exception). It's unfortunate, but the support was going to go away sooner or later, just having to update to keep things supported means it's perhaps faster than folks thought it would be.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No milestone
No project
No assignees
6 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
fesco/tickets#3707
No description provided.