Reconsider team representatives on Mindshare #154

Open
opened 2026-10-05 14:16:03 +00:00 by shaunm · 8 comments
Member

The composition of the Mindshare Committee is defined to include the FCA, four elected program administrators, one Marketing Team Representative, and one Comm Ops Representative. The Comm Ops and Marketing reps are currently vacant.

In the last Mindshare meeting, we discussed whether these roles still make sense, and whether other teams should have a representative.

My proposal is that each term, Mindshare decides which two teams they would like to extend a representative position to, based on activity or current needs. I found two lists of teams:

I know Documentation and Magazine were mentioned as potential teams that could have reps.

I like the idea of having flexibility in which teams get reps each year, but I'm concerned it could lead to some unpleasant interactions each year if we decide to replace one team with another.

The [composition of the Mindshare Committee](https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/mindshare-committee/#composition) is defined to include the FCA, four elected program administrators, one Marketing Team Representative, and one Comm Ops Representative. The Comm Ops and Marketing reps are currently vacant. In the last Mindshare meeting, we discussed whether these roles still make sense, and whether other teams should have a representative. My proposal is that each term, Mindshare decides which two teams they would like to extend a representative position to, based on activity or current needs. I found two lists of teams: * https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/mindshare/ * https://docs.fedoraproject.org/en-US/mindshare-committee/teams/ I know Documentation and Magazine were mentioned as potential teams that could have reps. I like the idea of having flexibility in which teams get reps each year, but I'm concerned it could lead to some unpleasant interactions each year if we decide to replace one team with another.
Member

I am happy to open the two positions to people from any SIG.

Anyone could put themselves forward, and the broader elected Mindshare can then vote them in.

I am happy to open the two positions to people from any SIG. Anyone could put themselves forward, and the broader elected Mindshare can then vote them in.
Owner

Ditto, @theprogram.

Per the previous meeting, we can either have them open up to elections or representatives from certain subprojects.

From the top of my head, I can think of AI, Moderation and Documentation folks where most activity is happening.

These parts of the community could use some representation and this could be our opportunity to do just that IMHO.

Ditto, @theprogram. Per the previous meeting, we can either have them open up to elections or representatives from certain subprojects. From the top of my head, I can think of **AI**, **Moderation** and **Documentation** folks where most activity is happening. These parts of the community could use some representation and this could be our opportunity to do just that IMHO.

We (Docs) might be interested. We'll discuss this in our space first and let you know.

We (Docs) might be interested. We'll discuss this in our space first and let you know.
Owner

Coming from the related CommOps ticket, I would like to formally offer the resignation of the CommOps seat in the Mindshare Committee charter on behalf of the CommOps Team, due to our inability to find a successor for the Mindshare Committee seat.

Coming from the [related CommOps ticket](https://forge.fedoraproject.org/commops/tickets/issues/145), I would like to formally offer the resignation of the CommOps seat in the Mindshare Committee charter on behalf of the CommOps Team, due to our inability to find a successor for the Mindshare Committee seat.
Owner

Alright, so (probable) +1 from the documentation (@pbokoc, please do confirm the same), (definitive) -1 from the community operations (@jflory7, thanks for the confirmation), and +0 from the AI and the moderation sides, as of now. Is this something that the AI representatives (eg. @jflory7, @sumantrom, @sdharane etc.) and the moderation team (tagging in the most recently seen ones without overlap, @py0xc3, @ankursinha, @computersavvy, @gbcox etc.) would be interested in?

We have not heard anything back from the marketing but I assume it is going to be the same as the community operations, as unfortunate as it sounds. For what its worth, we will remain open to having them back as and when the activity there increases over a duration and warrants the Mindshare representation. As of October 2026, that does not seem to be the case, and hence, as the digital ambassadorship Mindshare representative, I want this to be a formal resignation of that charter seat.

Alright, so (probable) +1 from the documentation (@pbokoc, please do confirm the same), (definitive) -1 from the community operations (@jflory7, thanks for the confirmation), and +0 from the AI and the moderation sides, as of now. Is this something that the AI representatives (eg. @jflory7, @sumantrom, @sdharane etc.) and the moderation team (tagging in the most recently seen ones without overlap, @py0xc3, @ankursinha, @computersavvy, @gbcox etc.) would be interested in? We have not heard anything back from the marketing but I assume it is going to be the same as the community operations, as unfortunate as it sounds. For what its worth, we will remain open to having them back as and when the activity there increases over a duration and warrants the Mindshare representation. As of October 2026, that does not seem to be the case, and hence, as the digital ambassadorship Mindshare representative, I want this to be a formal resignation of that charter seat.

moderation team (tagging in the most recently seen ones without overlap, @py0xc3, @ankursinha, @computersavvy, @gbcox etc.) would be interested in?

I generally like the idea, but if the mods are represented, I think they should select their representative themselves. I open a topic in the mod area with reference to this. Thanks for pinging :)

Supplement for people with tl3 or higher access: Discourse mod area topic.

> moderation team (tagging in the most recently seen ones without overlap, @py0xc3, @ankursinha, @computersavvy, @gbcox etc.) would be interested in? I generally like the idea, but if the mods are represented, I think they should select their representative themselves. I open a topic in the mod area with reference to this. Thanks for pinging :) Supplement for people with tl3 or higher access: [Discourse mod area topic](https://discussion.fedoraproject.org/t/moderation-team-to-have-a-representative-in-mindshare-committee/206104).
Owner

@py0xc3, of course, of course. We have already spent half our term with those seats empty so I would much rather give it the time and attention that it needs. Also, I see @theprogram doing some amazing work with helping with the questions in that thread!

@py0xc3, of course, of course. We have already spent half our term with those seats empty so I would much rather give it the time and attention that it needs. Also, I see @theprogram doing some amazing work with helping with the questions in that thread!
Member

We have an expression of interest from one person from the Discourse Moferation / tl3/tl4 team.

We have an expression of interest from one person from the Discourse Moferation / tl3/tl4 team.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No project
No assignees
6 participants
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference
mindshare/tickets#154
No description provided.